Sunday, June 1, 2008

Social Studies: Individual Reflection on Democracy

What is Democracy?

According to Webster’s online Dictionary, it is “a government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised by them directly or indirectly through a system of representation usually involving periodically held free elections”.

However, Democracy has many different forms. Hence, in this post I will be talking about my opinions about the two different types of Democracy.

An example of a country that mainly employs Direct Democracy is Switzerland. Direct democracy empowers the people to call a referendum either to initiate or to block legislation, which effectively puts the steering wheel of government into the hands of the people and takes it out o the hands of an unresponsive elite with its own agenda.

The main advantages of this form of Democracy, in my opinion, are that it restores authority to the people, making them responsible for policy. This creates a people-driven government instead of a usual elite-driven government. It affects the country by curbing the imbalanced use of power, making politicians servants of the people. In the social aspect, is also generates community involvement and creates a society where there is a sense of national ethos and people are politically conscious.

However, the main disadvantages of this form of Democracy is that the citizens may get voter’s fatigue, where they are tired of voting on political matters which breeds indifference to the political arena. Moreover, the government and media will try to influence the people’s votes.

Personally, I do not think that this form of Democracy is not very feasible as it would cause much social disruption in society as people often have to take time out to vote for even insignificant matters. In the long term, people would be very “tired” of voting and this would eventually wipe out interest in political matters due to the overbearing amounts of referendums, etc.

Representative Democracy is a form of democracy wherein voters choose representatives (through elections) to act in their interest. An example of a state that employs Representative Democracy is the United Kingdom. These legislative powers lie mainly with the representatives, however.

The main advantages of this form of Democracy is that voters are less likely to get voter’s fatigue and it is favorable where technology and population figures are not suitable for direct democracy. As a testimony to its success, a majority of the world’s population lived in representative democracies. Not only has it become the most successful form of civics since absolute monarchy, it also consists of most of direct democracy’s advantages such as generating community involvement while having less of its disadvantages like the danger of voter’s fatigue.

However, some of its disadvantages consist of the fact that it is still partly elite-driven and authority still is somewhat government-controlled.

Personally, I feel that Representative Democracy is the best and most suitable form of democracy in today’s society. There is no doubt an interest in politics among citizens, but technology is not evenly distributed among the population to be suitable for direct democracy as it would very inconvenient. Though it sacrifices a small amount of freedom on the people’s part, it greatly eases the convenience of people when deciding on important decisions like the US Bill of Rights.

As a whole, I feel Democracy is indeed very idealistic and liberalistic. Not only does it emphasize on equal rights and freedom of speech, it is also suitable for the world’s society as more and more people are being influenced by the liberal mindset. Although it does have its short-comings in terms of the dangers of creating a social divide, I believe that with a strong government which implements this policy will be able to overcome the disadvantages.