Social Studies: Individual Reflections
By: Michael Lee (18) 3A
“Democracy creates stability in a society.”
According to Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, the only way to guarantee that men do not fly airplanes into buildings is to have a democratic transformation of the Middle East.
However, we must first examine: What is Democracy in the first place?
According to Wikipedia, Democracy is a system of government by which political sovereignty is retained by the people and exercised directly by citizens. The process of democracy is usually heralded by rallies, votings and in recent time, debates.
How does Democracy ensure stability in a society?
Ideally, Democracy allows the authority of making political decisions to be left to the citizens to decide for themselves. They decide who the government is and who is not, clearly reflecting the people's choice, and hence, there would be no reason to have riots or revolts against a government which they themselves have elected. If the people are unhappy with the current government, they can always vote them out in the next elections. This ensures stability in the society.
For example, in the past with the authoritarian societies (such as in the case of Myanmar), the government was often corrupt and did not pay attention to the people’s needs. This resulted in unhappiness and the people did not have the power to overrule the oppressive government. Ultimately, riots ensued when the monks decided to stage a “peaceful” protest which scaled into a bloodshed which disrupted stability in the society. However, if Myanmar was a democratic state, this would not have happened as the unsatisfied people could have not voted for the current political party in power.
However, Democracy does have its shortcomings as well and it does not ensure stability in the society all the time.
When faced with a dishonest government, Democracy will become extremely distorted. For example in the case of individual democracy, everyone votes for the one option. This is an accurate measurement of the people's opinions. However, due to factors like political corruption, voting results may be negatively impacted and the votes would be changed in the government’s favour. This results in political instability as the unsatisfied people would revolt. For example in Sri Lanka, the democratic government is at constant war with insurgent groups (such as the Tamil Tigers) although Democracy is meant to “ensure stability”. Some of the Tamil extremists felt that the democratic government was ostracizing the Tamils and hence took violent precautions.
In conclusion, I believe that there is no "best" form of governance in today's world and society which ensures stability. Instead, the best "form" of governance for ensuring stability depends on every individual state's own community and needs. According to Madeleine K. Albright, “Just because the denial of political freedom is bad does not mean that the exercise of Freedom will always be to our liking. Democracy is a form of government, it is not a ticket to some heavenly kingdom where all evil is vanquished and everyone agrees with us.” Democracy will not always ensure stability in the world today.
By: Michael Lee (18) 3A
“Democracy creates stability in a society.”
According to Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, the only way to guarantee that men do not fly airplanes into buildings is to have a democratic transformation of the Middle East.
However, we must first examine: What is Democracy in the first place?
According to Wikipedia, Democracy is a system of government by which political sovereignty is retained by the people and exercised directly by citizens. The process of democracy is usually heralded by rallies, votings and in recent time, debates.
How does Democracy ensure stability in a society?
Ideally, Democracy allows the authority of making political decisions to be left to the citizens to decide for themselves. They decide who the government is and who is not, clearly reflecting the people's choice, and hence, there would be no reason to have riots or revolts against a government which they themselves have elected. If the people are unhappy with the current government, they can always vote them out in the next elections. This ensures stability in the society.
For example, in the past with the authoritarian societies (such as in the case of Myanmar), the government was often corrupt and did not pay attention to the people’s needs. This resulted in unhappiness and the people did not have the power to overrule the oppressive government. Ultimately, riots ensued when the monks decided to stage a “peaceful” protest which scaled into a bloodshed which disrupted stability in the society. However, if Myanmar was a democratic state, this would not have happened as the unsatisfied people could have not voted for the current political party in power.
However, Democracy does have its shortcomings as well and it does not ensure stability in the society all the time.
When faced with a dishonest government, Democracy will become extremely distorted. For example in the case of individual democracy, everyone votes for the one option. This is an accurate measurement of the people's opinions. However, due to factors like political corruption, voting results may be negatively impacted and the votes would be changed in the government’s favour. This results in political instability as the unsatisfied people would revolt. For example in Sri Lanka, the democratic government is at constant war with insurgent groups (such as the Tamil Tigers) although Democracy is meant to “ensure stability”. Some of the Tamil extremists felt that the democratic government was ostracizing the Tamils and hence took violent precautions.
In conclusion, I believe that there is no "best" form of governance in today's world and society which ensures stability. Instead, the best "form" of governance for ensuring stability depends on every individual state's own community and needs. According to Madeleine K. Albright, “Just because the denial of political freedom is bad does not mean that the exercise of Freedom will always be to our liking. Democracy is a form of government, it is not a ticket to some heavenly kingdom where all evil is vanquished and everyone agrees with us.” Democracy will not always ensure stability in the world today.